Website design / Practical guide
How to Compare Website Redesign Quotes on the Same Scope
A useful website redesign quote explains what will change, who supplies the content and how the finished site will be checked. Give each supplier the same brief, separate the initial build from ongoing costs, and resolve missing scope before comparing the totals.

Write down the decision the website needs to support
Start with the customer task that prompted the redesign. A visitor might need to understand a specialist service, compare products or send a project enquiry. Name the page or journey where that task currently breaks down.
Give suppliers the same evidence: the existing URL, recurring customer questions and a short description of what you want the visitor to do. Remove personal details from example enquiries. A proposal can then explain which changes address that task.
For an advisory practice, a hypothetical objective might be: help a visitor identify the relevant service and contact the right person. This is more useful for quoting than a request to make the website modern. If you are still comparing providers, our website agency guide covers the earlier selection step.
Count content pages and reusable layouts separately
A ten-page website may use three reusable layouts, or it may contain ten distinct experiences. List the actual pages, the layouts they share and any special behaviour. Ask each supplier to price against that list.
Include mobile navigation, forms, search, downloadable resources and error states where they matter. State whether a content management system is required and which parts staff need to edit.
The Governiq Advisory project shows a service directory, an About section and a contact route. Use those published screens as an example of naming distinct parts of a brief. They do not establish the scope, price or results of your redesign.

Sources: Governiq Advisory website case study
Assign every piece of content and every connection
Record who writes, edits, approves and uploads the copy. Do the same for images, translations and downloadable files. A quote that assumes approved content supplied by the client covers different work from one that includes interviews and copywriting.
Describe integrations by the action they must complete. For an enquiry form, name the destination, required fields, confirmation shown to the visitor and the person who will test receipt. Ask what happens if submission fails.
List the systems you already use and who controls access. Confirm any software, font, image or plugin licences needed for the proposed solution. Keep passwords out of the comparison document.
An example scope line
Enquiry form: six agreed fields; validation and a clear error message; delivery to the nominated inbox or CRM; successful submission confirmed to the visitor; receipt checked by the client. Ask each supplier to identify any setup or third-party charges. This is a hypothetical requirement, not an existing DBS price.
Deliverable
What the supplier will provide: for example, a reusable service-page layout.
Owner
Who supplies approved copy, images and system access, and who approves the result.
Acceptance
The specific task or output both sides will review before the item is complete.
A practical comparison framework. Apply the same fields to every proposal.
Include the work needed to preserve useful existing URLs
Give suppliers a list of pages that currently receive visits or enquiries, along with downloadable resources and important images. State which addresses should stay and which are expected to change.
If URLs change, ask who prepares the old-to-new URL map, implements redirects, updates internal links and checks the sitemap. Google’s site-move guidance describes preparation, URL mapping, redirects and monitoring. Request these as named deliverables when they apply.
A new design does not require a new address for every page. Discuss each proposed change with the developer and agree who monitors the site after launch. Search positions can fluctuate during a move; a quote cannot guarantee that rankings will stay fixed.
Google’s discussion explains why URL changes and migration need their own plan. Use it to ask what migration work is included in a redesign quote. It is an older overview; use the current written guidance cited in this section for implementation.
Video: Site Migrations: SEO Mythbusting by Google Search Central. Creator’s notes.
The YouTube player connects only when you press play. You can also use the video link above.
Agree how the finished work will be accepted
Turn broad promises into checks that both teams can review. Name the important visitor tasks, the devices and browsers to cover, and the person who signs off. Include real content in those checks.
For accessibility, ask what standard and scope the supplier is working toward, which evaluation methods are included and how reported issues are handled. W3C recommends evaluation throughout a redesign and explains that tools alone cannot establish accessibility.
For usability, ask someone who resembles the intended customer to try a realistic task. GOV.UK’s testing guidance describes observing people completing tasks and thinking aloud. Agree whether recruitment, sessions and resulting revisions are included in the quote.
Put performance and enquiry tracking into the same acceptance discussion. Specify the pages and test conditions instead of asking for a universal score. Confirm that a real enquiry reaches its intended destination; a working button alone does not complete that check.
Sources: W3C: evaluating web accessibility · GOV.UK: moderated usability testing
Compare the same period, currency and assumptions
Separate initial project work from recurring hosting, software and support. Choose a comparison period, such as twelve months, and apply it to every proposal. Request a breakdown of optional work and charges that depend on usage.
For suppliers quoting in USD, GBP, CAD or EUR, keep the original currency visible and record the date of any conversion you use internally. Ask each supplier to state whether quoted amounts include applicable taxes. Confirm payment milestones and what triggers each invoice.
A missing price for a required task is an open question. Mark it as unpriced until the supplier confirms the scope and amount. Do not treat a blank cell as zero.
Ask how many review rounds are included, what counts as a scope change, who owns the editable files and accounts, and what support follows launch. Compare the answers alongside the total.
A comparison formula
Comparable total for the chosen period = confirmed initial scope + mandatory third-party setup + recurring charges for that period + priced required extras. Keep optional work and unresolved items visible separately. This formula is a worksheet, not a market price estimate.
Confirmed initial scope
Design, development, content and migration included in the signed proposal.
Required ongoing costs
Hosting, licences and agreed support over your chosen comparison period.
Unresolved or optional work
Keep unpriced required items open. Show optional additions separately.
No sample prices are implied. Ask suppliers to price the missing required work before comparing totals.
Resolve the gaps before choosing
Send each supplier the same list of unanswered questions. Keep the replies with the proposal revision they clarify. If an answer changes the price or delivery plan, ask for an updated document.
Use the checklist below to review the scope before comparing the final totals. It records whether the proposals are ready for a decision; your team still needs to judge the quality of the work and the working relationship.
Try it with your project
Your selections stay on this page until you leave or refresh. Copy them to keep a record.
Your next step
Make your redesign scope comparable.
Send DBS your current URL, the pages you need to keep, the journeys you want to improve and the systems the website must connect to. We can scope design and development around that brief.
Discuss your website redesignWhat happened when you tried?
Which line in your current website proposal is hardest to compare with the alternatives?
Share your feedback
Email us directly at hello@designerbstudio.com.
Replies go to our inbox; they are not posted publicly. Please leave out verification codes and identity documents.